Escrow in Turkey: A Complete Guide for Foreign Property Buyers
Navigating property transactions in a foreign country can be complex, and for many international buyers, the concept of "escrow" is a familiar and reassuring safeguard. However, when considering buying property in Turkey, it's crucial to understand that the Turkish legal system does not operate with a direct, identical "escrow" service as commonly understood in Anglo-Saxon jurisdictions like the United States or the UK.
This doesn't mean that secure property transactions are impossible or that buyers are left unprotected. On the contrary, Turkey has its own robust, albeit different, mechanisms and legal frameworks designed to ensure the safety and legality of property transfers. The key lies in understanding these Turkish-specific processes, leveraging the right legal expertise, and adhering to diligent practices.
This comprehensive guide aims to demystify the concept of "escrow in Turkey" for foreign property buyers. We will explain what escrow typically entails, why a direct equivalent doesn't exist in Turkey, and most importantly, how foreign buyers can achieve a high level of payment security and transactional safety through a combination of legal safeguards, professional supervision, and disciplined financial practices. Our goal is to empower you with the knowledge to make informed decisions and secure your investment when buying property in Turkey safely.
What Does Escrow Mean in a Property Transaction?
In its most common form, an escrow service acts as a neutral third party that holds funds, documents, or other assets on behalf of two other parties involved in a transaction. The escrow agent, often a bank, a title company, or a specialized escrow firm, is bound by a contractual agreement (the escrow agreement) to release these assets only when all specified conditions of the underlying transaction have been met.
For instance, in a typical property sale, the buyer would deposit the purchase funds into an escrow account. The seller would deposit the property's title deed and other necessary documents. The escrow agent would then hold these until all conditions, such as the completion of inspections, resolution of any liens, and final signing of transfer documents, are satisfied. Once all conditions are met, the escrow agent simultaneously releases the funds to the seller and the title deed to the buyer. This simultaneous exchange minimizes risk for both parties, ensuring neither party performs their part of the deal without the other party fulfilling theirs.
The primary benefits of an escrow system are:
- Security: Funds and documents are held by a neutral party, protecting both buyer and seller from fraud or default.
- Impartiality: The escrow agent acts without bias, following the agreed-upon instructions.
- Conditional Release: Assets are only released upon the fulfillment of predefined conditions, ensuring a fair exchange.
Understanding this traditional definition is vital for foreign buyers approaching the Turkish market, as it highlights the differences in how payment security is achieved.
Is There a Standard Escrow System in Turkey?
The short answer is no, there isn't a "standard escrow system" in Turkey that mirrors the Anglo-Saxon model described above. The Turkish legal framework for real estate transactions is fundamentally different, particularly regarding the role of a neutral third-party holding both funds and the title deed simultaneously.
In Turkey, the official transfer of property ownership occurs at the Land Registry and Cadastre Directorate (Tapu Müdürlüğü), commonly referred to as the Tapu Office. This is where the official title deed (Tapu) is registered and transferred from the seller to the buyer. The Tapu Office is a government institution responsible for recording all property ownership and related rights; it does not, however, act as an escrow agent. It facilitates the transfer but does not hold funds on behalf of the parties.
The Turkish system places a strong emphasis on the official registration process at the Tapu Office as the definitive act of ownership transfer. Until the title deed is officially registered in the buyer's name, the buyer does not legally own the property, regardless of any payments made or contracts signed. This distinction is paramount and underpins why an escrow system, as understood elsewhere, is not natively integrated into the Turkish process.
While there have been discussions and some limited initiatives to introduce escrow-like services, particularly through banks, these have not become a widespread or standardized practice for residential property sales. Therefore, foreign buyers should not expect to engage a traditional escrow company in Turkey. Instead, the focus shifts to alternative, legally sound methods for securing payments and ensuring a safe transaction.
How Escrow-Like Arrangements Are Used in Practice
While a direct escrow service is absent, foreign buyers in Turkey can achieve a high level of transactional security through a combination of contractual safeguards, legal oversight, and meticulous financial practices. These "escrow-like arrangements" are designed to mitigate risks, particularly concerning the transfer of funds before the official title deed registration.
1. Lawyer-Managed Client Accounts (Under Strict Conditions)
A common method to provide an escrow-like function is through a Turkish real estate lawyer. A reputable and licensed Turkish lawyer can, in certain circumstances, hold a client's funds in a designated client account. This arrangement provides a layer of security because:
- Professional Responsibility: The lawyer is legally and ethically bound to act in the client's best interest and disburse funds only according to explicit instructions and upon the fulfillment of agreed-upon conditions.
- Conditional Release: The lawyer can be instructed to release the funds to the seller only after the title deed has been successfully transferred into the buyer's name at the Tapu Office. This ensures simultaneity of exchange.
- Transparency: All transactions are documented, and the lawyer provides a clear audit trail.
However, it's crucial to select a highly reputable and experienced lawyer. Not all lawyers offer this service, and the regulations around client accounts can vary. This method is often preferred for initial deposit payments or for holding the final payment until the Tapu transfer. Turk Estate Legal can guide you on such arrangements and provide Turkish escrow service through our legal team, ensuring your funds are handled with the utmost care and professionalism.
2. Conditional Payment Clauses in Preliminary Contracts
A preliminary sales contract (often notarized) can be drafted with specific clauses that link payment installments to critical milestones. For example:
- An initial deposit (usually 1-10% of the purchase price) upon signing the preliminary contract.
- A larger payment upon the seller providing all necessary documentation for the Tapu transfer.
- The final and largest payment to be made at the Tapu Office simultaneously with the official title deed transfer.
This contractual approach provides a legal framework for payment security. If the seller fails to meet a condition, the buyer is legally protected from making further payments and may have recourse for damages or deposit recovery, depending on the contract terms.
3. Direct Bank Transfers Linked to Tapu Registration
This is perhaps the most common and secure method for the final payment. The buyer transfers the purchase funds directly to the seller's bank account at the Tapu Office on the day of the official transfer.
- Simultaneity: The bank transfer is initiated and confirmed by the bank representatives present at the Tapu Office (or via online banking) after the Tapu official confirms all conditions for transfer are met and before the final signature that registers the new owner.
- Proof of Payment: The bank transfer creates an undeniable record of the transaction, which is crucial for legal and tax purposes. The Tapu Office requires proof of payment (bank receipt) for the property value declared.
- Reduced Risk: By making the final payment at the point of transfer, the buyer minimizes the risk of losing funds if the transfer somehow falls through at the last minute.
4. Use of Official Bank Receipts and Payment Confirmation
Turkish law requires that all property payments be made via bank transfer to ensure transparency and prevent money laundering. The Tapu Office will require proof of these bank transfers. This system, while not an escrow in itself, provides a crucial layer of accountability and traceability. A reputable lawyer will ensure all payments are properly documented and declared.
By combining these strategies, foreign buyers can create a robust "escrow-like" environment that protects their investment throughout the property acquisition process in Turkey.
Key Risks for Foreign Buyers Before Title Deed Transfer
Purchasing property in any country carries inherent risks, and Turkey is no exception. For foreign buyers, these risks can be amplified by unfamiliarity with the local legal system, language barriers, and cultural differences. Before the crucial title deed (Tapu) transfer, several key risks must be meticulously addressed to safeguard your investment.
1. Seller Default or Disappearance
One of the most significant risks is the seller backing out of the deal after receiving partial payment, or worse, disappearing with the funds. Without the official Tapu transfer, the buyer has no legal claim to the property. While preliminary contracts offer some protection, recovering funds from a defaulting or absent seller can be a lengthy and challenging legal process. This risk underscores the importance of not transferring significant funds before the Tapu registration.
2. Hidden Debts, Liens, or Mortgages
A property might be encumbered by various financial obligations unknown to the buyer. These can include:
- Mortgages: Existing loans secured against the property.
- Enforcement Orders/Seizures: Court-ordered attachments due to the seller's unpaid debts.
- Property Taxes: Unpaid municipal taxes or utility bills.
- Inheritance Issues: Disputes among heirs if the property is part of an inheritance.
- Construction Debts: Debts related to the construction of the property, particularly relevant for new builds.
If these encumbrances are not identified and cleared before the Tapu transfer, the new owner could inherit these liabilities. This is a primary reason why thorough real estate due diligence in Turkey for foreign investors is indispensable.
3. Property Not Matching Description or Zoning Issues
The property advertised might not accurately reflect its legal status or physical condition. Risks include:
- Illegal Construction: Parts of the property built without permits or in violation of zoning laws.
- Incorrect Zoning: The property's designated use (e.g., residential, commercial) might not match the buyer's intentions or the seller's claims.
- Lack of Occupancy Permit (İskan): For new builds, the absence of an Iskan (habitation certificate) can lead to utility connection problems and potential fines.
- Discrepancies in Size/Boundaries: The actual plot size or property dimensions might differ from what's stated in the Tapu records or marketing materials.
These issues can lead to significant legal and financial headaches post-purchase, or even render the property unusable for its intended purpose.
4. Fraudulent Sellers or Agents
Unfortunately, fraudulent activities can occur. This might involve:
- Impersonation: Someone pretending to be the owner or authorized agent.
- Selling the Same Property Multiple Times: A scammer attempting to sell the same property to multiple unsuspecting buyers.
- Forged Documents: Presenting fake title deeds or other official documents.
Engaging a reputable Turkish real estate lawyer and conducting thorough due diligence are the best defenses against such criminal acts.
5. Foreign Buyer Restrictions and Legal Compliance
Turkey has specific regulations regarding foreign property ownership, including nationality restrictions, military zone proximity, and limits on total land area. Failure to comply with these regulations can invalidate a sale or lead to difficulties in obtaining the Tapu. A lawyer ensures that the buyer meets all legal requirements and that the property is eligible for foreign ownership. For more detailed information, consider reading our guide on buying property in Turkey as a foreigner.
Mitigating these risks requires professional legal assistance, meticulous due diligence, and a clear understanding of the Turkish property transfer process.
Why Transferring Money Before Tapu Registration Is Risky
The single most critical piece of advice for foreign property buyers in Turkey is to avoid transferring the bulk of the purchase money before the official title deed (Tapu) registration. This is not merely a recommendation; it is a fundamental safeguard against significant financial loss and legal complications.
Here's a detailed breakdown of why pre-Tapu payment is inherently risky:
1. No Legal Claim to the Property
In Turkey, legal ownership of a property is established only when the buyer's name is officially registered on the title deed (Tapu) at the Land Registry and Cadastre Directorate. Until that moment, regardless of any preliminary contracts signed or money transferred, the buyer does not legally own the property. If you transfer money before the Tapu is in your name, you have paid for something you do not yet legally possess.
2. Difficulty in Recovering Funds
If the sale falls through after you've transferred money but before the Tapu registration, recovering those funds can be extremely challenging.
- Seller Default: If the seller decides not to proceed with the sale, or sells the property to someone else, you would have to initiate a lengthy and costly legal process to reclaim your money.
- Seller Disappearance/Insolvency: If the seller disappears or declares bankruptcy, your chances of recovering the funds diminish significantly.
- Fraud: In cases of outright fraud, tracing and recovering funds can be nearly impossible, especially if the money has been quickly moved offshore.
3. Exposure to Hidden Debts and Liens
As discussed, a property might have undisclosed debts, mortgages, or other legal encumbrances. If you pay before these are fully identified and cleared, you risk losing your money or even inheriting these liabilities. The due diligence process aims to uncover these issues, but if payment is made prematurely, the leverage to insist on their resolution is lost.
4. Lack of Leverage
Your most significant leverage as a buyer is your money. By holding onto the majority of the purchase price until the moment of Tapu transfer, you ensure that the seller has a strong incentive to complete the transaction smoothly and clear any outstanding issues. Once the money is transferred, that leverage is gone.
5. Potential for Scams and Fraud
Pre-Tapu payments are a common target for scammers. They might pressure buyers into making quick transfers, citing urgency or special deals, only to vanish with the funds. Without the direct oversight of the Tapu Office and a lawyer at the critical moment of transfer, buyers are more vulnerable to such schemes.
6. Tax and Legal Compliance Issues
Turkish law requires the full declared sale price to be transferred via bank. Payments made in cash or undeclared amounts can lead to legal penalties for both buyer and seller. Making payments prematurely or outside official channels can complicate compliance and create audit trails that are difficult to verify. For more insights into secure payment methods, refer to our article on safe payment for property purchase in Turkey.
In summary, while a small, refundable deposit might be necessary to reserve a property, the bulk of the payment should always be made simultaneously with the official transfer of the title deed at the Tapu Office, under the supervision of your Turkish real estate lawyer. This synchronicity is the closest equivalent to the security offered by a traditional escrow system in Turkey.
The Role of a Turkish Real Estate Lawyer
Engaging a qualified and independent Turkish real estate lawyer is not just recommended; it is absolutely essential for foreign property buyers. Given the absence of a standard escrow system and the complexities of Turkish property law, a lawyer acts as your primary safeguard, providing expertise, oversight, and representation throughout the entire buying process. This is particularly true when navigating payment security.
Here's why a Turkish real estate lawyer is indispensable:
1. Comprehensive Due Diligence
A lawyer conducts thorough real estate due diligence in Turkey for foreign investors on the property and the seller. This includes:
- Verifying Ownership: Confirming the seller's legal right to sell the property by checking the Tapu records.
- Checking for Encumbrances: Identifying any mortgages, liens, seizures, easements, or other debts registered against the property.
- Zoning and Permits: Investigating zoning status, building permits, and the occupancy permit (İskan) to ensure the property is legally compliant and suitable for its intended use.
- Tax and Utility Debts: Confirming that all property taxes, utility bills, and communal fees are paid up to date.
- Foreign Buyer Eligibility: Ensuring the property is in an area where foreign ownership is permitted and that the buyer meets all legal requirements.
2. Drafting and Reviewing Contracts
Your lawyer will draft or meticulously review all contractual agreements, including:
- Preliminary Sales Contracts (Sales Promise Agreements): Ensuring that all terms, conditions, payment schedules, and penalty clauses are clear, fair, and protect your interests. This includes specifying conditions for deposit release or forfeiture.
- Official Sales Contract (at Tapu Office): While largely standardized, the lawyer ensures the details are correctly recorded and understood.
They will ensure that any "escrow-like" arrangements, such as conditional payments or holding of funds, are clearly stipulated and legally enforceable. For more details on contracts, see our guide on property sale contracts in Turkey for foreign buyers.
3. Managing Payment Security
This is where the lawyer plays a critical role in providing "escrow-like" security:
- Advising on Secure Payment Methods: Guiding you on the safest ways to transfer funds, emphasizing bank transfers and avoiding cash payments.
- Conditional Fund Management: If offering a client account service, they will manage funds according to strict instructions, releasing them only upon the successful Tapu transfer.
- Supervising Tapu Office Payment: Ensuring that the final payment is made simultaneously with the official transfer of the title deed at the Tapu Office, providing real-time confirmation.
4. Representation and Translation
Your lawyer will represent you at the Tapu Office, handling all bureaucratic procedures and ensuring the smooth transfer of the title deed. They will also facilitate communication, bridging any language barriers and explaining complex legal terms.
5. Risk Mitigation and Legal Advice
Throughout the process, your lawyer identifies potential risks, advises you on the best course of action, and provides legal remedies if disputes arise. They are your independent advocate, ensuring your rights are protected.
6. Post-Purchase Assistance
After the Tapu transfer, a lawyer can assist with connecting utilities, registering the property with the municipality, and other necessary post-purchase steps.
In essence, a Turkish real estate lawyer acts as your trusted advisor, due diligence expert, contract negotiator, and payment supervisor, providing the most robust form of security available for foreign buyers in Turkey.
Common Secure Payment Methods in Turkey
Ensuring the security of your funds during a property purchase in Turkey is paramount. While a traditional escrow system is not standard, several secure payment methods, when combined with legal oversight, offer robust protection. The overarching principle is transparency and traceability, which is why cash payments are highly discouraged and often legally problematic.
1. Direct Bank Transfer at the Tapu Office (Recommended for Final Payment)
This is by far the most secure and widely recommended method for the final, substantial payment.
- Process: On the day of the official title deed transfer at the Tapu Office, the buyer initiates a bank transfer directly from their Turkish bank account (or international account if permitted by their bank) to the seller's Turkish bank account.
- Timing: The transfer is typically initiated after the Tapu official confirms that all conditions for transfer are met, the necessary fees and taxes are paid, and just before the final signatures that legally transfer ownership.
- Confirmation: Bank representatives (if available) or online banking confirmation can verify the transfer in real-time. The Tapu Office requires a bank receipt (dekont) as proof of payment for the declared sale price.
- Security: This method ensures near-simultaneous exchange of funds for the title deed, minimizing the risk of one party defaulting after the other has performed their part. Your lawyer will oversee this process.
2. Bank Transfer via a Lawyer's Client Account (for Deposits or Interim Payments)
As mentioned earlier, a reputable Turkish real estate lawyer may offer to hold initial deposits or interim payments in a dedicated client (fiduciary) account.
- Process: The buyer transfers funds to the lawyer's client account. The lawyer holds these funds according to a written agreement, releasing them to the seller only when specific, pre-defined conditions are met (e.g., successful Tapu transfer).
- Security: This provides an "escrow-like" function, as the funds are held by a neutral, legally bound professional.
- Caveats: This service depends on the individual lawyer and their firm's policies. Always ensure you have a clear written agreement detailing the conditions for fund release.
3. Notarized Preliminary Sales Contract with Conditional Payments
While not a payment method itself, a notarized preliminary sales contract (Satış Vaadi Sözleşmesi) can stipulate a structured payment plan where installments are tied to specific milestones.
- Initial Deposit: A small, usually refundable, deposit (e.g., 1-5% of the purchase price) might be paid upon signing this contract to reserve the property. The contract should clearly define conditions for refund or forfeiture.
- Subsequent Payments: Larger payments are then made only upon the fulfillment of specific conditions, with the final payment reserved for the Tapu transfer day.
- Security: This contractual framework provides legal recourse if the seller defaults on conditions, making it safer than simply handing over money without clear legal terms.
4. Avoiding Cash Payments
It is strongly advised to avoid making large cash payments for property in Turkey.
- Lack of Traceability: Cash transactions leave no official record, making it impossible to prove payment in case of a dispute.
- Legal & Tax Issues: Turkish law mandates bank transfers for property transactions to combat money laundering and ensure proper tax declaration. Undeclared cash payments can lead to severe penalties for both buyer and seller.
- Security Risk: Carrying large sums of cash is inherently risky due to theft.
Always insist on bank transfers for all property-related payments, and ensure your Turkish real estate lawyer oversees the entire financial transaction process. This disciplined approach is a cornerstone of secure property payment in Turkey.
Due Diligence Checklist Before Any Payment
Before committing any significant funds or signing any contracts, a thorough due diligence process is absolutely critical. This comprehensive investigation, ideally conducted by your Turkish real estate lawyer, is your primary defense against unforeseen problems and financial loss. This goes beyond just verifying the seller; it involves a deep dive into the property itself and its legal standing. For a more detailed guide, refer to our article on real estate due diligence in Turkey for foreign investors and our general guide on due diligence.
Here's a comprehensive checklist:
1. Verify Seller Identity and Ownership
- Tapu Record Check: Confirm the seller's identity matches the name(s) registered on the official title deed (Tapu). Ensure there are no discrepancies.
- Power of Attorney (if applicable): If an agent is acting on behalf of the seller, verify the validity and scope of their Power of Attorney. Ensure it explicitly grants the authority to sell and receive payment.
- Company Ownership: If the seller is a company, verify the company's legal standing, its authorized signatories, and that the property is indeed owned by the company.
2. Check for Liens, Mortgages, and Debts
- Tapu Registry Check: Obtain an official extract from the Tapu Office to check for any registered mortgages, liens, foreclosures, easements, or other encumbrances on the property.
- Municipality Debts: Verify with the local municipality that there are no outstanding property taxes, municipal fees, or other public debts associated with the property.
- Utility Debts: Check for unpaid electricity, water, gas, and internet bills.
- Management Fees (Aidat): For apartments or properties within complexes, confirm with the building management that all communal aidat fees are paid up to date.
3. Verify Zoning, Building Permits, and Occupancy Permit (İskan)
- Zoning Status: Confirm with the municipality the property's zoning status (e.g., residential, commercial, agricultural) and that it aligns with your intended use.
- Building Permit (Yapı Ruhsatı): For new constructions or recently built properties, verify the existence and validity of the building permit.
- Occupancy Permit (İskan Ruhsatı): This is crucial for new buildings. An Iskan certificate confirms that the building has been completed according to plans and is fit for habitation. Without it, connecting utilities can be difficult, and fines may apply.
- Compliance with Plans: Ensure the actual construction matches the approved plans. Any illegal additions or modifications can lead to demolition orders or fines.
4. Review Property Description vs. Reality
- Physical Inspection: Conduct a thorough physical inspection of the property to ensure it matches the advertised description and the details in the Tapu.
- Boundaries and Size: Verify the property's boundaries and actual size against the Tapu records and cadastral maps.
- Fixtures and Fittings: Clarify what fixtures and fittings are included in the sale.
5. Review All Contracts
- Preliminary Sales Contract: Your lawyer must review this document meticulously, ensuring it protects your interests, clearly defines payment terms, conditions for cancellation, and penalties.
- Sales Contract (at Tapu): Understand the contents of the official sales contract that will be signed at the Tapu Office.
6. Foreign Buyer Restrictions
- Nationality Restrictions: Ensure your nationality is eligible for property ownership in Turkey.
- Military Zones: Confirm the property is not located within a restricted military zone.
- Land Area Limits: Be aware of any limits on the total land area a foreigner can own in a particular district.
7. Valuation Report (Required for Foreigners)
- Official Valuation: A property valuation report (Ekspertiz Raporu) issued by a licensed SPK-approved expert is mandatory for foreign buyers. This report determines the official value of the property for tax purposes and helps prevent price manipulation.
By diligently following this checklist, ideally with the guidance of a Turkish real estate lawyer, you can significantly mitigate risks and ensure a safe and legally sound property purchase. For more information on verifying properties, see our article on how to verify a Turkish property before payment.
Typical Red Flags in Turkish Property Transactions
Being aware of potential red flags is crucial for foreign buyers to avoid scams and problematic transactions. If you encounter any of these warning signs, proceed with extreme caution and consult your Turkish real estate lawyer immediately.
1. Pressure to Pay Quickly or in Cash
- "Limited-time offer" or "another buyer interested": High-pressure tactics to rush you into making a payment without sufficient due diligence.
- Insistence on cash payments: A major red flag. Turkish law mandates bank transfers for property sales to ensure transparency and prevent money laundering. Cash transactions are untraceable and highly risky.
2. Unusually Low Prices
- "Too good to be true" deals: While bargains exist, a property priced significantly below market value should raise suspicions. It could indicate hidden problems, illegal status, or a fraudulent seller. Always cross-reference with a professional valuation.
3. Refusal to Use a Lawyer or Independent Advice
- Seller or agent discourages legal representation: Any attempt to dissuade you from engaging your own independent lawyer is a serious red flag. A legitimate seller has nothing to hide.
- Insistence on using "their" lawyer: While some agents might recommend lawyers, always ensure your lawyer is independent and represents your interests exclusively.
4. Lack of Clear Documentation or Reluctance to Provide Information
- Missing or incomplete Tapu (title deed): The seller should be able to provide a copy of the Tapu.
- Unwillingness to show building permits, Iskan, or cadastral plans: Essential documents for verifying the legality and status of the property.
- Vague answers or evasiveness: If the seller or agent avoids direct questions about the property's history, debts, or legal status.
5. Agents Promising "Shortcuts" or Bypassing Formalities
- Suggesting to declare a lower sale price: This is illegal and can lead to severe tax penalties for both parties.
- Offering to "handle everything" without proper legal steps: Be wary of anyone who claims to simplify the process by skipping official procedures or due diligence.
6. Inconsistencies in Information
- Discrepancies between advertised information and official documents: The property's size, features, or legal status might be misrepresented.
- Different individuals claiming to be the owner or authorized agent: Always verify identity against official Tapu records.
7. Unregistered or Unlicensed Agents
- Operating without a valid real estate agent license (Emlak Danışmanı Belgesi): Ensure your agent is registered with the local Chamber of Commerce and has the necessary credentials.
- Lack of a physical office or professional online presence: While not always a red flag, it's a factor to consider.
8. Request for Payment to a Third-Party Account
- Asking you to transfer funds to an account that is not the registered owner's: Unless it's a verified and agreed-upon lawyer's client account, this is highly suspicious.
By staying vigilant and trusting your instincts, you can identify these red flags and avoid potentially costly mistakes. Always prioritize thorough due diligence and the advice of
This content is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Each transaction should be assessed according to its own facts and current legislation.
Need Legal Review Before You Pay?
If you want case-specific legal guidance before signing documents or transferring funds, contact Lawyer Ceren Sumer Cilli directly.
